India's Akash Air Defense Missile System Offer for the Philippine Navy

Some defense outlets have made rounds in reporting that three countries in Asia are interested in having an air defense system that has produced by a country like India, whose aspiration for defense arms exports is now getting set into motion. The Philippines, apparently, is one of those three countries said to be interested in obtaining this system.

IN THE NEWS
Akash Air Defense Missile System of the Indian Armed Forces. Image Source.

Three countries - Vietnam, United Arab Emirates, and the Philippines, have expressed their interest in procuring Akash Air Defense Missile System for their respective nation's air defense needs, as India ramps up its defense export needs after the success of its export sale to the Philippines for its BrahMos Anti-Ship Missile System.

This came after the Indian government recently approved the export of these indigenously made air defense systems, with it most likely to be an export variant intended for other countries that has expressed the interest in procuring them, as opposed to the ones currently in service within the Indian Armed Forces.

This shows India's aspirations in entering the Defense Export Market, competing with established industries originating from the United States, Russia, France, Italy, the United Kingdom, China, and others, wherein getting a significant portion will help boost their reputation as an arms exporter, while providing an industry that will help grow the domestic Indian economy in the long run.

Apparently, this air defense missile system is one of those systems being showcased for the Philippine Navy's Shore-Based Air Defense Missile System Acquisition Project, a fully different project and not to be confused with the Shore-Based Anti-Ship Missile System Acquisition Project that the BrahMos Aerospace's Anti-Ship Missiles won as the preferred system for the project.

In this article, we will purely discuss the development and background of the making of the Akash Air Defense Missile System, as well as providing its specifications and providing comparisons to the RAFAEL SPYDER Ground-Based Air Defense System that the Philippine Air Force will have in its inventory, and also an idea fully related to logistical and commonality of military defense platforms across the Armed Forces of the Philippines ecosystem.

INDIA'S DEFENCE RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT ORGANISATION
This Indian Postage Stamp defines India's Defence Research and Development Organisation as an entity.
Image Source.

Website: http://www.drdo.gov.in/

India's Defence Research and Development Organisation or known as the DRDO, is an entity that specializes in what its name describes for - research and development of Indian defense and military technology that can add or improve the country's effort to have its indigenous defense industry, focusing to the production of its own military assets and technological innovation similar to the United States' DARPA or Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency.

Some of its known indigenously made products that have researched and developed as part of improving India's military capabilities include the well-known BrahMos Cruise Missile System, in which it was a fruit of a joint development between the DRDO and the Russian Defense Company NPO Mashinostroyeniya, with the BrahMos design clearly derives from the P-800 Oniks/Yakhont Missile system that produced from Russia. The BrahMos Missile System is the first export of an Indian-made defense product to a foreign country, with the Philippines as its first export customer of the missile system.

Aside from the BrahMos Missile System, DRDO also took part in researching and developing other indigenously made defense technology and military assets, as part of its efforts by the Indian Government in pursuing a reliable defense industry. The effort comes as a part of the greater "Make In India" initiative in improving its industry as a hub for producing different goods and products for their economic development, defense industry included. These include the LCA (Light Combat Aircraft) Tejas that are intended for both the Indian Air Force and Navy and helped provided key avionics for the Indian Air Force Su-30MKI. 

Also, they assist companies like the Hindustan Aerospace Limited in the development of their programs like the HAL Dhruv Advanced Light Helicopter, in which this was currently being pushed for the Philippine Coast Guard as part of their offer, coming alongside with the Dornier Do-228 aircraft that is also included in the offer, as these are to be provided through a loan or what they say as a "line of credit" from India.

As many of the indigenous defense products that the Defence Research and Development Organisation has made to improve India's Defense Industry and in enhancing the capability of India's Armed Forces, it is at no doubt that India is now going outward to push defense equipment that are Made in India, now pitching their Akash Air Defense Missile System after the successful export of the BrahMos Missiles to a country like the Philippines.

DEVELOPMENT
Akash Prime test launch on 27 September 2021. (c) DRDO, via Wikimedia Commons.

The Akash Air Defense Missile System has inducted and entered the active Indian Military Service way back in 2007, at the time where multiple tests of the air defense system have made and showed its performance in the process in terms of accuracy, consistency, and reliability as these are the basis for both the Indian Air Force and Indian Army before officially getting the indigenously made system as part of their firepower capability.

While the induction has done in 2007, the indigenous development of what will be the Akash Air Defense Missile System has made two decades prior. Way back in the 1980s, India began indigenous development of a medium range air defense missile system that has sought as a replacement to the Soviet-era made SA-6 Gainful (2k12 Kub) air defense system, in which the Akash have apparently derived from this system that India primarily used during that time.

Given the resemblance between the Akash and the SA-6 Gainful, let us discuss the background of the latter, of which this was a 1960-era Soviet technology that was introduced into the Armed Forces of the Soviet Union in 1967 and has showcased in a Moscow military parade of the same year. This air defense system was both effectively used by Egypt and Syria in the 1973 Yom Kippur War against Israel, especially in the early days of the war.

As for the test flights, it took India at least a decade until the first ones have started in the 1990s, with enhancements and tweaks have ensured as part of the ongoing development of the indigenous air defense system primarily intended for the Indian Armed Forces, wherein it took them a decade and a half more before the first production and induction phase at around 2005/2007.

Currently, India's Defence Research and Development Organisation, along with the Indian Armed Forces, is still developing the Akash air defense missile system that multiple variants have produced since its induction in the mid-2000s and since then became part of the Indian Armed Forces' air defense system umbrella, now intending to export it to other countries like the Philippines.

SPECIFICATIONS
Akash Missile System's features and Physical Parameters.
Image Source.

Like any other air defense system configurations available such as Israel's SPYDER Ground-Based Air Defense System, the AKASH Air Defense Missile System setup comes with several batteries, each coming with its own quantity of Akash Missile Launchers and radar units, although it also comes with a Group headquarters that serves as a primary Command and Control Unit that oversees operation of each AKASH Air Defense Missile batteries deployed.

The Physical parameters provided on the screen grabbed part of the document above (accessible here), pertains to the AKASH Missile munition itself, wherein it has a diameter of 35 centimeters (converted) and a length of 582 centimeters (also converted). This means that the size of the AKASH Missile itself is larger than the Python Missile, with its 16 centimeter diameter and 310 centimeter length, while having a lighter weight coming at 105 kilograms compared to AKASH's 720 kilograms.

Likewise, the AKASH Missile munition itself, as compared to the "I-Derby Missile", still comes heavier as the latter comes with 118 kilograms, while keeping the same diameter size with the Python Missile at 16 centimeters and having a lengthy size at around 362 centimeters, although it is still smaller than the overall size that came with the AKASH Missile System munitions as its design has derived from Soviet-era technology compared to the modern technological design that goes with both Python and Derby Missiles (munitions that form the RAFAEL SPYDER Ground-Based Missile System).

As for the range, the AKASH Missile's integral Ram Rocket Propulsion has said to provide a thrusting range up to 25 kilometers, far less than the RAFAEL SPYDER MR (Medium Range) Ground-Based Air Defense System that has the approximate coverage of at least 40-60 kilometers. AKASH Air Defense Missile System's capabilities can be more comparable to the RAFAEL SPYDER SR (Short Range) variant that has the range of 20 kilometers, with the former having a slight advantage of only just 5 kilometers.

That being said, capability-wise, the RAFAEL SPYDER MR Ground-Based Air Defense System that the Philippine Air Force will get is far more capable than India's AKASH Air Defense Missile System that it offers to the Philippine Navy, wherein it will make more sense if the naval branch will just settle on the same air defense system made in Israel as this also comes with a practical approach in terms of logistics and interoperability.

WHAT REMAINS TO BE SEEN
Israel's RAFAEL SPYDER Ground-Based Air Defense System (GBADS), is just one of many offers made for the Philippine Navy's Shore-Based Air Defense System Acquisition Project. Image Source.

The deal that India offers for its AKASH Air Defense Missile System for the Philippine Navy falls under the said naval branch's Shore-Based Air Defense System Acquisition Project, which came with multiple offers from other suppliers that have taken part in the biddings, one of which includes the Israeli defense firm RAFAEL and its product the SPYDER Ground-Based Air Defense System or GBADS.

Speaking of SPYDER Ground-Based Air Defense System of Israel, it has successfully chosen by the Philippine Air Force for its Ground-Based Air Defense System Acquisition Project, giving RAFAEL access to the Philippine military and defense market, gaining a portion in the market in the process while providing their product that effectively improves the country's air defense system, giving a significant air cover in the national airspace.

The Shore-Based Air Defense System Acquisition Project of the Philippine Navy comes with the same aim as the Ground-Based Air Defense Acquisition Project of the Philippine Air Force, with the difference being the end-user of each project and if the Akash Air Defense Missile System became the preferable option, the defense system of choice that each of the military branches uses for their air defense capabilities and getting an effective air cover for the portion of the country's airspace.

However, the Armed Forces of the Philippines, like any other organization, are fond of having commonality between military assets, especially in employing systems in the field that benefit them regarding improvement of the logistics chain of spare parts and maintenance of each system, not to mention that the offer made by the Israeli firm RAFAEL counts as more modern, capable, and more sophisticated, than the India's AKASH Air Defense Missile System with its design derived from Cold War Soviet Tech.

It remains to be seen as to the outcome of this deal as India approved this deal for export and an offer for the Philippine Navy's Shore-Based Air Defense Acquisition Project, not to mention that India sees first successful export of its BrahMos Anti-ship missiles to the Philippine Navy, while it sees stiff competition with its competitors especially Israel's air defense system that is already being used by the people in the Philippine Air Force. 


(c) 2022 PDA.
Share:

Knowing the Specifications of the HHI's Philippine Navy Corvette

The Philippine Navy Corvette Acquisition Project will be the largest project for the naval branch of the Armed Forces of the Philippines, surpassing the current capabilities and sophistication of its new Jose Rizal-class Frigates, in terms of firepower and threat detection.

The shipbuilder who built the will provide the said project will be the South Korean company Hyundai Heavy Industries, the conglomerate that also built the Jose Rizal-class Frigates.

IN THE NEWS
HDC-3100, Corvette, Philippine Navy
The prospect design of the Corvette Acquisition Project, patterned after the Hyundai Heavy Industries' HDC-3100 design. Hyundai Heavy Industries, image got via Naval News.

Last December 28, 2021, the Philippine Department of National Defense and Hyundai Heavy Industries signed the contract for the production and delivery of two units of warships under the Philippine Navy's Corvette Acquisition Project, which is one of the big-ticket projects that has successfully materialized under the Second Horizon of the Revised Armed Forces of the Philippines Modernization Program (R.A. 10349).

This was after the Philippine Navy bid out the Acquisition Project to prospective bidders that have taken part in the project, with Hyundai Heavy Industries and Turkey's ASFAT being one of those participants, with their offers being the HDC-3100 design and the MiLGEM (Ada-class corvettes), respectively. Both of which have their separate discussions on this website, in which they are accessible by just clicking the links highlighted in red above.

With the contract now signed, we expect that both the Department of National Defense and Hyundai Heavy Industries, along with the officials from the Philippine Navy, will undertake the next process of the Acquisition Project, which is the Critical Design Review, wherein there will be some tweaks with the design, and it will be done with finishing touches before issuing the Notice to Proceed document, allowing the shipbuilder to start the work in manufacturing the ships, starting with a ceremonious steel cutting ceremony between the shipbuilder and the end-user of the upcoming vessels.

As for the Critical Design Review stage, we expect things to be smooth, given that some subcomponents of the new Corvettes are getting compatible or aligning to the specifications provided for the HDF-2600 design, or what is now the Jose Rizal-class Frigates. Also, the design improvements are getting tackled in this stage, with the completed and improved version serving as the reference for the shipbuilder like the Hyundai Heavy Industries to produce these vessels.

Since that the project has made it to this point, let us discuss the specifications of the HDC-3100 design, wherein we can say that the Corvettes will come as a more capable vessel packed with more firepower, as compared to the Jose Rizal-class Frigates that produced by the same shipbuilder, especially that these new ships will come with extra weaponry that are lacking or currently not found onboard the Philippine Navy's current sophisticated warships.

SPECIFICATIONS
Philippine Navy, Corvette Acquisition Project, HDC-3100, Hyundai Heavy Industries
The same CGI as the first one from Hyundai Heavy Industries, although it now comes with an infographic that points out potential subsystems, basing from logistical data and info from other defense outlets.

Note: The infographic content provided above isn't totally complete, as things may still change in Critical Design Review, regarding the subcomponents which either originated from existing subcomponents onboard the Jose Rizal-class Frigates as a reference (as this will make sense from a logistical and commonality point of view), and with other information originated from other defense outlets as specified in the infographic itself.

Update as of May, 5 2022: Hyundai Heavy Industries chose Israel Aerospace Industries' ALPHA 3D AESA radar for the Philippine Navy's primary radar system for the two new HDC-3100 Corvettes, of which it came in either 200 nautical mile or 400 nautical mile coverage (and this remains to be seen). Previously, the radar selection for the project was unknown, labeled on the infographic as an AESA 4D Radar. Check this article for reference use.

Given the infographic above, we observed that there are several subcomponents that are currently unavailable onboard the Jose Rizal-class Frigates will find its way to the new Corvettes, considering that the Corvette Acquisition Project itself does not have any provisions that will count a sensor system or weapons subcomponent as a "Fitted For, But Not With" or "FFBNW" item, a thing that the Jose Rizal-class Frigates have, wherein its current unavailable subcomponents may get bought separately.

The known subcomponents seen here, that are also seen onboard the Jose Rizal-class Frigates, are the 76mm Oto Melara Super Rapid Gun, with an older variant being the mainstay gun for both the Del Pilar-class Offshore Patrol Vessels and the Jacinto-class Patrol Vessels, and these three indigenously made South Korean subcomponents such as the Hanwha System's Naval Shield Integrated Combat Management System, LIGNex1 SSM-700K C-Star Anti-Ship Cruise Missiles, and K745 Blue Shark Torpedoes.

The interesting subcomponents that were added in the Corvette Acquisition Project, that are not available currently in the Jose Rizal-class Frigates, are the ASELSAN GOKDENIZ 35mm Close-In Weapons System (CIWS) from Turkey, and the 16-cell MBDA VL-MICA Vertical Launch System, both of which are helpful in adding necessary air defense for the two new warships of the Philippine Navy.

We will discuss these two aforementioned subsystems as we get along with this article, focusing more on its capabilities and specifications, while briefly discussing the developments surrounding these subsystems, although an in-depth discussion for both the GOKDENIZ CIWS and the MBDA ML-MIVA VLS, especially in its background, deserves its own separate discussion in a separate entry.

ASELSAN GOKDENIZ 35MM CLOSE IN WEAPONS SYSTEM (CIWS)
The Turkish-developed and produced Close-In Weapons System or CIWS. Image Source.

As one of many weapons subcomponents installed onboard the new HDC-3100 designed Corvettes of the Philippine Navy, the Turkish company ASELSAN plays a role in providing an essential defense weaponry that eliminates air threats like incoming drones or Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) and anti-ship missile, giving a layer of protection that keeps these sophisticated warship and its crew from harm of destruction and casualty.

Aside from eliminating incoming UAVs and anti-ship missiles, the GOKDENIZ 35mm Close-In Weapons System (CIWS) can eliminate enemy helicopters, fighters, and asymmetrical surface naval threats, at least coming from the brochure of ASELSAN and with these mentioned capabilities serving as a main selling point for the Turkish defense company intended for prospective customers that has seen interest in having this weapons system fitted onboard their warships.

Also, the GOKDENIZ 35mm Close-In Weapons System can eliminate threats coming from Unmanned Aerial Vehicles or UAVs, as well as both subsonic and supersonic anti-ship missile threats that can pose the threat against the survival of the new Corvettes of the Philippine Navy and its crew onboard, as this system comes with an Automatic Linkless Ammunition Feed Mechanism as a feature, which it allows the loading of both HEI and Airburst Ammunition at the same time and switching between the said ammunition types as required.

The GOKDENIZ itself is a sea derivative of the Korkut Self-Propelled Air Defense Gun System, itself also developed by Turkish defense company ASELSAN for land-based air defense operations specifically for the Turkish Land Forces, in collaboration with another Turkish Defense Company FNSS Savunma Sistemleri, wherein the first units of such type were first produced in March 2017, and delivered to the Turkish Army in May 2018.

The Gokdeniz Close-In Weapons System (CIWS) comes with an automatic target tracking feature with an integrated tracking platform, which it includes a tracking radar and electro-optics sensors, with the optional configuration for a 3-D radar sensor installation wherein the air defense close-in weapons system can detect air targets at a range of up to 70 km.

The discussion of the Turkish Close-In Weapons System in-detail will provide in a separate article, as it will deal more with the development of the system and its timeline, detailed specifications, and other information that will specifically focus on this topic about the Turkish-made subcomponent that gets its way to the new Philippine Navy Corvettes.

16-CELL MBDA VL-MICA VERTICAL LAUNCH SYSTEM
A systems configuration of a 16-cell MBDA VL-MICA Vertical Launch System.
VL MICA MG is an improved derivative of the same family of Vertical Launch Systems. 
Image Source.

MBDA's VL-MICA Vertical Launch System is basically a sea-based version of the VL-MICA Ground-Based Air Defense System, which is a ground-based air defense variant of the MICA multi-mission air-to-air missile that is fitted onboard multirole fighter aircraft like the Rafale and the later variants of the Mirage 2000 Multirole Fighter Jets, both made by the French Aerospace Company Dassault Aviation. 

This comes with the similar concept of the Philippine Air Force's upcoming SPYDER Ground-Based Air Defense System from Israel's Rafael Advanced Defense Systems Ltd, wherein the SPYDER GBADs are a variant of both Python and Derby missiles, both of which are air-to-air missile munitions produced by Rafael for the Israeli Air Force, all of which have developed by Rafael Advanced Defense Systems Ltd.

Aside from the Rafale and the later variants of the Mirage 2000 Multirole Fighter Jets of Dassault Aviation, the MICA multi-mission air-to-air missile can also fit onboard the SAAB JAS-39 Gripen Multirole Fighter Jets, of which it is one platform showcased for the Philippine Air Force's Multirole Fighter Jet Acquisition Program, which have no updates currently and may go more likely as a Horizon 3 project at the time this article has published.

MICA as an air-to-air missile munition started development in the 1980s by France's Matra Electronics, intended as a replacement for the R-550 Magic Short-Range Missile and the R-530 Beyond Visual Range (BVR) Missile, both of which have also developed by the said French company. MICA has abbreviated in French which, if translated, means "interception and aerial combat missile".

Like the Turkish GOKDENIZ Close-In Weapons System (CIWS), the MBDA VL-MICA 16-Cell Vertical Launch System serves as an additional layer of air defense system installed onboard the new Philippine Navy Corvettes, assuring that the ship and its crew gets fully protected against incoming threats from the air, ranging from other aircraft to anti-ship missiles. 

The in-detail information of the French-made Vertical Launch System will cover on a separate article, discussing its specifications, detailed information on its development, and variants made through the years since its introduction to the French Armed Forces, particularly the French Air Force.

OTHER KNOWN SUBCOMPONENTS
Specifications of the Jose Rizal-class Frigates. Correction: The design derived is from HDF-2600, and not HDF-3000. PDA/Max Defense.

This article will not be complete without discussing other subsystems that can be available on warships that are already in service with the Philippine Navy fleet, especially the ones found onboard the Jose Rizal-class Frigates, the base design that the HDF-3100 is now being derived from and both are designs from Hyundai Heavy Industries of South Korea.

Like the Jose Rizal-class Frigates, the HDC-3100 Corvettes that the Philippine Navy is about to have later on will come with LIGNex1 SSM-700K C-Star Anti-Ship Missiles, now comes at the 4x2 configuration or 8 anti-ship missile launch canisters, as opposed to only 4 launch canisters at 2x2 configuration that are found on the Jose Rizal-class Frigates. This means that the new Philippine Navy Corvettes came with more firepower that itself is a force reckoned with against naval threats at sea.

Another will be the SEA J+S Triple Torpedo Launchers, wherein it designs to load K-745 Blue Shark Torpedoes, produced by South Korea's LIGNex1, the same company that produces the SSM-700K C-Star anti-ship cruise missiles that were originally developed and made for improving the Republic of Korea Navy's firepower capabilities, with its export prospects now growing as this may likely came onboard the Philippine Navy corvettes based on easing logistics and keeping commonality of subcomponents across its naval vessels.

As for its Combat Management System, chances are likely that it will still be the Naval Shield Integrated Combat Management Systems of South Korea's Hanwha Systems, given that its integration on both the Jose Rizal-class Frigates and the Del Pilar-class Offshore Patrol Vessels, although it remains to be seen whether they will introduce either the Baseline 2 found on the Jose Rizal-class Frigates, or the newer Baseline 3 that Hanwha made as an improved variant of the Naval Shield family of Combat Management Systems.

Completing the list will be the mainstream Oto Melara Super Rapid 76mm gun that belongs to the Oto Melara family of main guns that are found on the primary warships of the Philippine Navy's Offshore Combat Force, Rigid-Hull Inflatable Boats or RHIBS that are available on the fleet's capital warships which include the Tarlac-class Landing Platform Docks, and typical S and X-Band Sharpeye navigational radars from Kevin Hughes.

WHAT REMAINS TO BE SEEN
A Jose Rizal-class Frigate taking part in Amphibious Operations as part of AJEX DAGIT-PA 2021.
Image Source.

The Philippine Navy is continuously pursuing its modernization efforts under the Navy Sail Plan 2028, although in a diminished form that only few big-ticket projects have passed through the procurement process and has guaranteed its materialization and implementation of the production and delivery process, such as in the case for the Corvette Acquisition Project and the Offshore Patrol Vessel Acquisition Project that is expected to be awarded to Austal shipbuilding from Australia.

This new corvette design from Hyundai Heavy Industries of South Korea, although derived from the HDF-2600 that the Jose Rizal-class Frigates based from, will be more sophisticated and will have more firepower than what the said brand new Frigates that the Philippine Navy currently has, giving an improvement for the maritime branch of the Philippine Armed Forces with regards on having capital warships in its fleet that has sufficient anti-ship, anti-submarine, and anti-air capabilities at its disposal.

Take note that once again, the design and subcomponents for the HDC-3100 Corvette Design of the Hyundai Heavy Industries will have finishing touches under the Critical Design Review, although most of the subcomponents, basing on commonality and easing logistical chain, will pattern to what the Jose Rizal-class Frigates currently have, now with additional armaments in its disposal like the Vertical Launch System and Close-In Weapons System and will not go as a separate item under typical FFBNW provisions.

For the other subcomponents that are counted as currently unknown, it will determine through time as defense updates will come in and add additional information on the overall composition of the HDC-3100 Corvette Design, as this will provide a clear picture for the capabilities of what will be the Philippine Navy's newest warships in its fleet upon entry into service a year or two from issuing Notice to Proceed documentation that starts production of the warships.

Now that a notice of award has provided to the Hyundai Heavy Industries, and a contract has signed between the South Korean shipbuilder and the Department of National Defense, it is only a matter of time to see the new Philippine Navy Corvettes taking shape and seeing its capabilities, as it will eventually gets introduced into the fleet as an active vessel that is capable to defend the country's national interest on both of its territorial and exclusive economic zone waters and domains like in the West Philippine Sea.


(c) 2022 PDA
First revision 5-5-2022.
Share:

Additional S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters for the Philippine Air Force?

The last batch of the S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters has just arrived in the country from Poland's Sikorsky subsidiary plant of PZL Mielec. This completes the physical delivery of the Combat Utility Helicopters and will be part of the Air Force's desire to modernize its fleet of both rotary and fixed-wing aircraft in its inventory. What will it be with the leadership if it adds more of such type of helicopters to its operations?

IN THE NEWS
One of two S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters assigned in Zamboanga City's Edwin Andrews Airbase.

The Philippine Air Force inventory of S-70i Blackhawk helicopters has just boosted to its completion as the last batch of five units of the Combat Utility Helicopter disembarked from the Antonov An-124 Ruslan cargo freighter aircraft which was operated by an Ukranian airline of the same name.

It comprises the 16-unit Combat Utility Helicopter Acquisition Project that the Philippine Air Force bought from Sikorsky Helicopters, made in Poland through a Sikorsky subsidiary known as PZL Mielec. Sikorsky Helicopters itself is a subsidiary of the American defense firm Lockheed Martin, the company that produces C-130 cargo aircraft and F-16 Fighters, both of which are currently being offered to the Philippine Air Force.

In relation to this, there were reports that the Philippine Government gave a go-signal to the procurement of additional S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters for the Philippine Air Force to use, although it was uncertain from that time whether to buy just 15 units of these Combat Utility Helicopters, or to buy 32 more units as what the Secretary of National Defense said on the report that might bring the total number of S-70i Blackhawk helicopters to 48 units.

As the geographical nature of the Philippines and its land area have shown, one can really say and with mere common sense that 16 Blackhawk Helicopters aren't enough to cover all the combat utility operations of the Philippine Air Force, at least if we limit it to this type of helicopters and not to account the other Combat Utility Helicopters that the air branch of the Armed Forces of the Philippines possesses, such as the UH-1 Huey and Bell 412 Helicopters.

That being said, this topic will discuss the in-depth perspective of the viability of having additional S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters of the Philippine Air Force by gathering as much data as possible from multiple fully credible sources and to connect the dots from that point down to the tiny, significant detail which will give a glimpse on how will this idea go to the air branch, as far as its importance is concern.

THE COMPOSITION OF COMBAT UTILITY HELICOPTERS WITHIN PAF
The Philippine Air Force, aside from the S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters, also have both Bell 412s and Bell UH-1 Combat Utility Helicopters, each coming with its own capabilities and concerns. Image Source.

Before the S-70i Blackhawk Combat Utility Helicopters entered service within the Philippine Air Force, most of the asset that comprised this category are usually the Bell UH-1 Iroquois (Huey) Helicopters that were traced back from 1960s/1970s during the height of the Vietnam War, or the succeeding ones that derived from the original UH-1 Iroquois design, such as the Bell 412EP Helicopters (or the Canadian C-146 Griffon, as seen in the image above).

Just recently, last October 15, 2021, the Philippine Air Force decommissioned its 10 UH-1D Iroquois (Huey) Helicopters, effectively dropping them from active service. The primary attributes that have led to the decisions are the following - first, the Philippine Air Force saw another accident involving a helicopter of this type, and second is more of the S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters are entering the service, effectively replacing these UH-1Ds that the Philippine Air Force categorize as an "interim" service platform.

Currently, based on the information provided from Flightglobal website on world air force composition for the year 2021, the Philippine Air Force currently has at least eight (8) Bell 412EPs, twenty-three (23) UH-1H/D Huey Helicopters, and eight (8) Bell 205  (still basically counted as Bell UH-1H) Combat Utility Helicopters. This comes alongside the prospective number of S-70i Blackhawks of sixteen (16) units, totalling overall to 55 Combat Utility Helicopters, and this does not account for the 10 decommissioned UH-1Ds, along with the UH-1H crash that took place January 2021 (since the Flightglobal data was last updated from the year 2020), lowering it down to at least 44 units left.

The plan of buying 32 additional units of S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters, if pushed through, will give an overall number of Combat Utility Helicopter units in the Philippine Air Force up to the total of at least 76 unit helicopter fleet, a significant boost for the air branch of the Armed Forces of the Philippines and its desire in boosting up the numbers of combat utility helicopters that are helpful in both combat and peacetime operations, especially in humanitarian help and disaster response.

As operating an older fleet of aircraft comes with increasing expenses on maintenance, repair, and operations itself, it is just logical to go after newer assets, provided that there are budgetary resources that will allow a procurement of that large scale to happen. With this, it is interesting to see the recent actions from the people in the Department of National Defense, as well as within the Armed Forces of the Philippines, in the development that represents an idea of adding more S-70i Blackhawks in the Air Force.

DEVELOPMENTS
A batch of five (5) S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters of the Philippine Air Force delivered in the country.
Image Source.

In this latest video, as the Department of National Defense secretary Delfin Lorenzana reported before President Duterte dated November 15, 2021, he detailed his visit to Poland and his itinerary being related to the S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters, which he provided information that the Philippine Air Force, through the Department of National Defense, has set a new order for 32 additional said Polish-made, American-designed Combat Utility Helicopters, alongside the 16 units that were recently delivered.

This has seen as a good news, following-up the report from February that the Philippine Government has given a go-signal on the purchase of these additional Blackhawk Helicopters, allowing the boost of the number of Combat Utility Helicopters in the Philippine Air Force inventory, effectively making the S-70i Blackhawks as the mainstay Combat Utility Helicopter platform of the air branch with an overall number of 48 units.

The numbers provided may simply replace the UH-1H/D Iroquois (Huey) Helicopters as the most commonly used Combat Utility Helicopter platform in the Philippine Air Force once pushed through, and as this trend continues, it may help the air branch to replace the older Helicopter platforms eventually, while boosting its capabilities up that effectively helps deploy troops, supplies, and services in times of conflict and natural calamities.

While the announcement made by the Secretary of National Defense counts as good news, it remains to be seen on how far will this push through, as the process of documentation, budgeting, U.S. Government approval, and other factors can still determine the outcome and there may be changes along the way without notice such as any sudden cancellation of the project, or reduction of the number of units bought.

It is interesting to see how far the project will go, especially with the Secretary of National Defense reported that a new order for additional S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters has set up, although additional details related to financing and other important indicators for this development may go provided in a future update of added information.

ASSIGNMENT ON DIFFERENT AIRBASES
Two (2) assigned S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters flying over Zamboanga International Airport Terminal.
(c) Western Mindanao Command, FB Page

Just recently, the Philippine Air Force assigned these newly purchased Combat Utility Helicopters in some of its air bases scattered across the country, four of which are currently deployed under the area of responsibility (AOR) of the Eastern Mindanao Command (EASTMINCOM). 

These are in both the Tactical Operations Wing-Eastern Mindanao Davao Air Station in Barangay Sasa, Davao City and the Tactical Operations Group regional headquarters at Lumbia Airport in Cagayan de Oro. Both of the Philippine Air Force installations get two S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters each, forming the four-unit composition under the Eastern Mindanao Command's AOR.

Another pair of S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters is also being deployed in Western Mindanao Command's area of responsibility, particularly in Zamboanga City's Edwin Andrews Airbase (EAAB, see image above). This means that there are at least six (6) out of sixteen (16) units of the newly purchased Blackhawk Helicopters that are put into different units of the Philippine Air Force assigned to the country's southernmost island group of Mindanao.

Just as with any other air assets deployed in these airbases that the Philippine Air Force has scattered in the country, the S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters will become a common sight for people, in the same manner that the UH-1 Huey Helicopters being a common sight as it operates routinely. This, although, comes with a hope that more may get added in these respective airbases for the years to come, especially with plans now on the pipeline.

This comes with a realization and a fact that having 16 units of Blackhawk Helicopters is still insufficient, with the plans of having 32 more Blackhawk Helicopters being a much-needed commitment for the current administration to carry, especially that having these newer platforms may allow the retirement of the older UH-1 Huey Combat Utility Helicopters that are still in service today.

THE CATCH
Some of the S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters sitting in an airbase. Image Source.

It is an achievement for both the Philippine Air Force and the Department of National Defense that all S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters purchased under the Combat Utility Helicopter Acquisition Project have gotten delivered successfully, despite that there was one unit that involved in a nighttime testing mission crashed near Capas, Tarlac, leaving no survivors at all and it resulted to the temporary grounding of the rest of the Blackhawks.

Aside from the 32-unit acquisition that the Philippine Air Force and the Department of National Defense recently discussed with the representatives of the Sikorsky subsidiary in Poland (PZL Mielec), there is an alternative plan, wherein the national security advisor of the current administration way back February 2021 discussed an acquisition of at least 15 units of S-70i Blackhawk Helicopters, almost half of the recent numbers provided.

Either the 32-unit acquisition or the 15-unit alternative that the national security advisor provided will improve the number of Combat Utility Helicopters that the Philippine Air Force is having, especially that it needs a lot of this rotary air platforms not only in deploying troops in areas of combat in the name of national defense, but also on humanitarian help and disaster response into areas affected by natural calamities in which such helicopters are very useful.

With this, it is interesting to see the outcome of the proposal, especially with the 32-unit proposal now setting into motion, as documentation and paperwork is still to be written for this plan to be materialized, and the eventual agreements of both sides for the project is still to be seen as there are still changes that might happen along the way as a way for both the seller and the buyer to benefit from the deal.

In the end, it will still be at the table of both the Philippine Air Force and the Department of National Defense regarding how far this project will go as far as planning and materialization is concern, although the numerical data provided still presents the fact that air assets like the Combat Utility Helicopters needs to be added more, as the air force's logistical requirements for both HADR and troops/supplies deployment increases.




(c) 2021 PDA.
Share:

The Dornier Do-228 Procuring Interest of the Philippine Coast Guard

The Philippine Coast Guard has the desire to improve its capabilities further, getting to where they see an interest in procuring more assets that fit its mission requirements, which now involve the use of soft loans from several countries the agency deals with.

They may add India alongside Japan and France to the list of suppliers that provided the tools to the country's primary maritime enforcement agency if they pursue the deal they have an interest in, especially in purchasing air assets for its air fleet.

DISCUSSION OVERVIEW
The Dornier 228 aircraft of the Indian Coast Guard.
(c) Jetphotos.net website.

In the last article, we discussed the Dhruv Advanced Light Helicopters that the Philippine Coast Guard is interested in purchasing from Hindustan Aeronautics Limited using India's credit line. We also provided an overview that involves the procurement of Dornier 228 aircraft, which will be the principal topic to be discussed thoroughly in this article.

This came in line with the same information provided through a known Indian defense outlet, The Defenstar, citing a certain Saurav Jha as they pointed the interest of the Philippines' maritime law enforcement agency in the purchase of at least eight (8) units of license-copied variants of the Dornier Do-228 produced by the said Indian Aerospace Enterprise.

The information provided by the source gave an insight into the Philippine Coast Guard's desire to modernize its air unit, in the same manner, that it did for white-hulled vessels recently bought, such as the Gabriela Silang-class Offshore Patrol Vessel from France and the BRP Teresa Magbanua Multirole Response Vessel from Japan. We consider both vessels as the agency's most capable vessels to date.

Currently, the Philippine Coast Guard's air unit primarily comprises Airbus H145 utility helicopters, the 3.7-ton Maximum Takeoff Weight (MTOW) rotary aircraft that provides that capability for the agency to conduct its search and rescue operations, as well as the agency's coastal patrol mandates. We will discuss full details for it in a separate article in the future as we tackle modernization-related matters within the agency along the way.

With the interest clearly shown that the Philippine Coast Guard is opting to buy Dornier Do-228 aircraft for its air unit, we will cover much about the origins of the aircraft and its designer. Also, details on how Hindustan Aeronautics Limited secured a licensing agreement that allows it to produce the aircraft, the specifications of the aircraft itself, and the capabilities it brings will also cover in this article.

THE AIRCRAFT DESIGNER
A Do-228NG Dornier Aircraft in RIAT 2012, along with the Dornier Aircraft Logo.
(c) user Airwolfhound, via Wikimedia Commons.
The logo got from Wikimedia Commons.

Dornier Flugzeugwerke was a known German aircraft manufacturer, founded in Friedrichshafen, in Southern Germany, near the borders of both Switzerland and Austria, by a man named Claude Dornier who was a known German airplane builder, with its technology founded its way into medical products produced by a once-medical subsidiary, now named as the Dornier Medtech. 

They found the company in 1914, with the specialty focused on making aircraft designs and producing them in numbers, helping Germany for its aviation needs in both the First and Second World Wars. It produced both civilian and military-based aircraft, intended to cater to both markets that sought a demand for having such aircraft produced by Dornier in their inventory.

There are many things that have happened to the company since then, especially with the sellouts that took place with Fairchild Aircraft buying Dornier from Daimler-Chrysler Aerospace (DASA), forming the Dornier Fairchild company that lasted only a couple of years until it went bankrupt in 2002. One of the reputable successors for Dornier itself is Deutsche Aircraft, a subsidiary of Sierra Nevada Corporation that produces Dornier 328 jets. The other successor is Dornier Seawings, a spinoff company made by the Dornier family itself. Airbus itself has a stake over Dornier Consulting International, the one that has the Dornier trademark in it that was sold recently to "Palero".

Given the number of exchanging hands of different companies that either has the original Dornier design or were once part of the original Dornier company, it is of no surprise that many of its designs are still in production today, such as the Dornier Do-228 that is now being done by India's Hindustan Aerospace Limited.

And with the existence of these designs comes as an opportunity for the Philippine Coast Guard to have them in case they pushed this deal through. Also, the proven Dornier design will help both India and the Philippines in securing this deal, as the latter will use this for their search and rescue, as well as conducting patrols in areas like the West Philippine Sea.

SPECIFICATIONS
Detailed technical specifications of the aircraft. Access to the PDF File Here.

As described by Hindustan Aeronautics Limited in a PDF snippet provided above, the Dornier-designed aircraft, being a high-wing monoplane with a cantilevered wing and two turboprop engines, have characteristics that see the benefit for an agency like the Philippine Coast Guard to use, such as its low fuel consumption, short take-off, and landing capabilities, among others described above.

Adding more information related to the technical specifications of the Do-228 aircraft, it comes with a passenger capacity of 19 people, while its 2 Garrett TPE 331-5 engines run at a power of 525kW or 704shp each (or 840 thermodynamic shaft horsepower as per its manufacturer), rotating each of the four-bladed reversible pitch Hartzell propellers that both engines have installed on. The Do-228 aircraft has the capable range of 600km or 324 nautical miles from point to point. 

As for the engines, it is currently being manufactured by Honeywell Aerospace, a company that specializes in the production of the TPE-331 engines that currently has 10 variants of the engine with different power outputs and overhaul hours, of which include the TPE-331-5 turboprop engines that powers the Dornier Do-228 that the Philippine Coast Guard aspires to get from India's Hindustan Aeronautics Limited.

Just like the engines, the Dornier Do-228 comes with six variant models, which are the Do-228-100, Do-228-101, Do-228-200, Do-228-201, Do-228-202 and Do-228-212. The aircraft system variant that the Hindustan Aeronautics Limited produces for its coast guard, for instance, is the Dornier Do-228-202 aircraft, while RUAG Aerospace (General Atomics since 2020), another manufacturer of the Dornier Do-228 aircraft, produces the more-advanced Do-228-212 (NG) aircraft.

The number of variants and manufacturers that still making this aircraft until today still shows that the viability and development of the Dornier Do-228 is still ongoing, with an agency like the Philippine Coast Guard showing interest in these air assets takes the advantage in its maintenance and operations, such as in the number of countries currently using this type of aircraft in service.

NUMBER OF USERS
RUAG Aerospace, another manufacturer of the Dornier Do-228, has delivered an aircraft of the type to a Japanese operator, New Central Airservice. Image Source.

Currently, there are many military and civilian operators of Dornier Do-228 that both RUAG Aerospace (General Atomics since the RUAG turnover in October 2020) and India's Hindustan Aeronautics Limited have produced for years. One of those operators is the Japanese New Central Airservice (as seen in the image above), wherein the former has delivered a fourth (4th) Do-228 aircraft to the Japanese air service operator in 2019.

Some of the most notable users of Dornier Do-228 in law enforcement field is the Netherlands Coast Guard, which uses two Do-228-212 aircraft in its air unit, the Royal Oman Police Air Wing, which uses two earlier variants of Do-228-100 aircraft for their operations, and of course, the Indian Coast Guard that gets a significant number of Dornier Do-228s from a manufacturer indigenous to their country like Hindustan Aeronautics Limited.

In the military use, meanwhile, some of the known users of the Dornier Do-228 is the Bangladesh Navy which, like the Netherlands Coast Guard, gets two Do-228-212 variants in its air unit. The German Navy also has a few Dornier Do-228s in its inventory, and the Royal Thai Navy and their use of the aircraft as an ISR (Intelligence, Surveillance, Reconnaissance) platform that patrols their Exclusive Economic Zone, much like in-line with the current objectives of the Philippine Coast Guard and their consideration in obtaining these air assets.

Aside from the military and law enforcement agencies that used the aircraft, several civilian operators have also used the aircraft, just like the Japanese operator NCA in the image above. They have different usage of the aircraft, but most of the civilian operators use the aircraft for air transport of cargo and passengers between smaller airports (as it was for the function of regional flights), or purposed charter flights in remote places like far-flung islands in the middle of the sea.

With the number of users coming from these three categories mentioned, the Dornier Do-228 sees its logistical viability that has advantages in the resource of spare parts and sees its reliability as a platform for surveillance and reconnaissance operations that a maritime law enforcement agency like the Philippine Coast Guard wants to improve as the organization grows and improves its overall capability through buying new assets and adding workforce through its pool of interested applicants.

WHAT REMAINS TO BE SEEN
Another angle of the Dornier Do-228 of the Indian Coast Guard. (c) Vincent Albert, via Flickr.

In the current inventory setup of the Philippine Coast Guard in terms of its fixed-wing composition, it primarily comprise the following aircraft - the older Britten Norman BN-2A Islander aircraft that came with two units, and the recently-procured Cessna Grand Caravan EX Multirole Aircraft, with only a unit purchased (both of which deserves to have its own discussion, later on).

Adding Dornier Do-228 in the Philippine Coast Guard's fixed-wing inventory will help improve the agency's capability especially in maritime surveillance, as it will help augment the two aforementioned assets of the maritime law enforcement agency in increasing its presence and maritime security in areas like in the West Philippine Sea.

Like the Airbus H145 that the Philippine Coast Guard also has purchased recently, the Cessna Grand Caravan EX Multirole Aircraft sees as a perception of complicating logistics for Dornier Do-228, in the same manner that it does with the HAL Dhruv Mk-3 Helicopter. The Philippine Coast Guard's interest in the Dornier Do-228 is related to the desired growth of the agency's air unit, with the help of India's line of credit.

The advantages in obtaining the asset, in the logistical point of view, is that there are many users of both government (military and law enforcement) and civilian operators that uses the Dornier Do-228 for their respective purposes, as either passenger and cargo hauling in remote areas, or surveillance and reconnaissance operations that the Philippine Coast Guard can have with these assets if considered.

It is still in the hands of high-ranking decision-makers of the Philippine Coast Guard in whether to pursue and materialize a project that will procure or purchase these utility fixed-wing aircraft. One is hopeful in seeing an improvement of the maritime law enforcement agency's air unit, especially in obtaining such an aircraft or its equivalent in its fleet.




(c) 2021 PDA.

Share:

Time

Translate

Articles

Total Pageviews To-Date

Webpage Visitors

Free counters!